People often ask us whether we can draft a completely ‘watertight’ puppy sale contract for breeders to use.  The short answer is that no contract is truly ‘watertight’ because enforceability depends on the facts of each case and the law that applies. 

However, a puppy sales contract can be legally binding, but only if it meets the legal requirements for a valid contract.  In most cases, a written contract helps clarify what was agreed between the breeder/seller and the buyer, but your legal rights may also depend on whether the seller is acting as a business or if they are a genuine hobby breeder / private seller.  Even if the sales contract is valid, it doesn’t necessarily mean that every clause is going to be enforceable.

At Cooper & Co, we regularly advise both puppy buyers and breeders on the enforceability of puppy sale contracts and puppy disputes, including refunds, damages claims, misrepresentation and consumer rights.

When is a puppy sale contract legally binding?

A puppy sale contract will usually be legally enforceable if it includes these four elements:

1. Offer – One party proposes specific terms.
2. Acceptance – The other party accepts those terms (or both parties agree a final set of terms after negotiation).
3. Consideration – Each party gives something of value (typically payment in return for the puppy).
4. Intention to Create Legal Relations – Both parties must intend for the agreement to be legally enforceable (not just casual or social).

A written agreement is not strictly required for a contract to exist, but a properly drafted written puppy contract is very helpful evidence if there is a dispute later.

Is the seller acting in the course of a business

This is a key legal question and is not always straightforward to determine.  If the seller is acting in course of a business the sale is usually governed by the Consumer Rights Act 2015. Under this Act the puppies are treated as ‘goods’ which means they must be:-

1. “of satisfactory quality” : The puppy should be healthy for its breed (not sick or injured).
2. “fit for purpose” : The puppy should be suitable for the reason you are getting it (e.g. as a pet, a working dog, etc provided that the particular purpose has been communicated to the seller).
3. “as described” : The puppy should match what the seller said (e.g. correct breed, age, sex, health status, paperwork).

Importantly, a business seller cannot exclude or limit these rights, even if the contract tries to do so. Any clause that seeks to exclude or limit these statutory rights will probably be unenforceable.

Common contract terms that can be enforceable

Some clauses are often enforceable, as long as they are fair and do not conflict with consumer protections:

1. Reasonable health – For example, that the puppy has received certain vaccinations, has been vet-checked, or that the seller discloses any known health issues.
2. Promises relating to Royal Kennel Club registration – Commitments that the dog is, or will be, registered with the Royal Kennel Club and that the registration papers will be provided as stated.

Terms that maybe unfair / difficult (or sometimes impossible) to enforce:

Some clauses can be legally questionable, especially where a seller is a business, such as:

1. Replacement-puppy-only clauses instead of offering a refund – the seller only offers another puppy, not money back.
2. Terms attempting to remove or limit a buyer’s statutory rights this means the contract tries to take away legal rights the buyer already has.
3. Strict breeding/neutering restrictions depending on how they are written and enforced – this means terms about breeding or neutering the dog that may be overly strict or unfair could be open to challenge.
4. Return to breeder clauses – Terms saying the dog must be returned to the breeder if you can’t keep it, instead of the buyer reselling or rehoming it. If this kind of clause is breached it could theoretically give rise to a nominal claim for damages, but this is very unlikely to lead to the dog being returned.

Buying from a private seller (genuine hobby breeder)

If the seller is not acting as a business, the Consumer Rights Act 2015 does not generally apply.  Instead, the legal principle of caveat emptor (let the buyer beware) is most likely to apply.

This means that your rights may be limited to:-

1. What was agreed in writing
2. What the seller represented about the puppy
3. General contract principles (including misrepresentation in some cases)

Li Goh-Piper

Solicitor

 

How we can help

If you need specialist legal advice in relation to your dog (or cat), please call us at Cooper & Co Solicitors on our landline number of 01227 20 33 20 during normal office hours.  Subject to a conflict check, we can usually offer a fixed fee telephone call for £75 + VAT for up to 20 minutes.

 

DISCLAIMER

This blog is provided for general information and does not constitute legal advice.  You should always seek tailored advice from a suitably qualified and experienced lawyer.

Cooper & Co Solicitors, 19 Palace Street, Canterbury, CT1 2DZ.

Tel : 01227 20 33 20
Email : admin@doglaw.co.uk  
Website : www.doglaw.co.uk

Regulated & authorised by the Solicitors Regulation Authority
SRA 258139